• Outlook User
  • Exchange Admin
  • Office 365
  • Outlook Developer
  • Outlook.com
  • Outlook Mac
  • Outlook & iCloud
    • Common Problems
    • Outlook BCM
    • Utilities & Addins

Outlook's Conversation Groups

Slipstick Systems

› Outlook › Outlook 2010 › Outlook’s Conversation Groups

Last reviewed on June 5, 2015     19 Comments

We hear a lot of complaints about the Conversation Groups that were introduced in Outlook 2010. They don't work as expected with Exchange 2003 or 2007, conversations don't stay expanded, and the old conversation view from older versions is not available.

The conversation group features uses a Conversation field to determine if the message belongs in a conversation with other messages. This works great with Internet mail accounts. It works great with Exchange 2010/2013. It doesn't work as well with Exchange 2007 or Exchange 2003, as both use the subject in determining which messages should group together.

The most noticeable effect on Exchange 2007/2003 users is that messages that don't belong in a "conversation" are grouped together anyway. As a result, users may have a lot of messages with the same subject grouped in a conversation. While this makes it easy to locate junk mail you need to delete, it's still annoying.

To make matters worse, if you group by conversation and add a category to a single message in your Inbox, other items with the same subject but in other folders will be categorized too, even if they don't belong to the conversation. This is because individual messages in the Inbox are both a message and a group header and adding a category to a group header adds the category to all messages within that group. While this is fine when the messages are all part of a conversation, it has unexpected results for Exchange 2007/2003 users.

When you apply a category to a conversation group, all new messages in the conversation will be categorized as they arrive, even if you turn Show as Conversations off. To stop this behavior, you need to remove the category from the conversation header.

In Show as Conversations view, click on the category in the Conversation group header (1 in the screenshot below). This will remove the category from all messages in the conversation. Add categories to individual messages if any need to be categorized. When you turn conversations off, new messages your receive in the conversation won't be categorized.
Conversation groups

We get many requests asking for help creating the conversation view found in older versions of Outlook. This view can't be replicated in Outlook 2010. Your choice is using the new conversation view or not grouping by conversation.

Another frequent request is the ability to keep all conversations expanded. This is not possible in Outlook 2010. Conversation groups ignore the Expand/Collapse default setting in View Settings > Group by.

'Show messages from other folders' Bug

First, appointments are grouped with messages with the same subject. These are not meeting requests that could be remotely considered part of the thread, they are totally unrelated appointments that just happen to have the same subject. Unfortunately, there is no way to remove the calendar folder from folders used in conversation grouping, other than by disabling 'Show messages from other folders' options.

The second bug is an interesting one. As we already know when using Exchange 2003 or 2007, messages with the same subject are erroneously grouped together but it’s a bit more tolerable when 'Show messages from other folders' is disabled (View ribbon, Conversation settings). However, if you have one message in the current folder and add a category to it using the quick click category field, every message that Outlook wants to group with this message (if Show messages in other folders was enabled) is also categorized. Ouch.

The workaround: Either turn off conversations or open the message and add the category.

It only appears to work like this with Categories, not Delete. When you delete a group of messages by selecting the group header, you only delete the messages in the current folder, not all messages in the conversation. Quick click categories should work much the same way (but don't) - if you can't see the message in the view, a category should not be applied.

Conversation View FAQ

While we're on the subject of the Conversation view in Outlook 2010, the following are frequently asked questions about the conversation view.

Q: Why do messages without a subject or with identical subjects group together when they are not in one conversation?

A: They should not group together when you are connected to a data store that is compliant with the new conversation logic. Exchange 2010 and native Outlook 2010 stores are compliant and should handle this correctly, but that's not my experience with messages from the Internet.

Q: Can you mark messages to remove them from the conversation?

A: No, there is no way remove (or add) messages from a conversation. The conversation is a grouping of all messages that are replies & forwards of the original message (except as noted in the previous question).

Q: How do you stop Outlook from including messages from other folders?

A: Go to the View tab, Conversation settings and deselect Show messages from Other Folders.

Conversations and Cached mode

I'm using Outlook 2010 RTM with an Exchange server mailbox and the ability to clean up conversations is disabled. What do I need to do to enable it?

The option to "Show Messages from Other Folders" is missing from Outlook 2010. The other 3 options are there. This is connected to an Exchange 2007 server with cached mode disabled if that makes any difference.

Yes, cached mode makes a big difference

Outlook's Conversation Groups was last modified: June 5th, 2015 by Diane Poremsky
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Print

Related Posts:

  • Conversation view
    Disable Outlook's Conversation View
  • Stop automatically assigning categories to all messages in a thread
  • Outlook's Conversation View isn't working
  • Disable Conversation View in Outlook.com and Outlook on the Web

About Diane Poremsky

A Microsoft Outlook Most Valuable Professional (MVP) since 1999, Diane is the author of several books, including Outlook 2013 Absolute Beginners Book. She also created video training CDs and online training classes for Microsoft Outlook. You can find her helping people online in Outlook Forums as well as in the Microsoft Answers and TechNet forums.

Subscribe
Notify of
19 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Mike (@guest_198377)
May 2, 2016 12:52 pm
#198377

Diane,

I use conversations exhaustively in Outlook (2013 and 2016 currently) and one item that I am surprised doesn't have a configuration option is the ability to disable auto-assigning categories to other emails contained within a conversation if the header email has a category.

Many times, I just want to tag the first email for future reference and\or searches but don't want every single email in that thread to have the same category.

Can you think of any way around this issue other than not to use conversations?

Here is a thread about it with my example in it.

Sincerely,
Mike

1
0
Reply
Heather (@guest_197448)
March 24, 2016 7:49 pm
#197448

Is there anyway to manually create a designation for the CONVERSATION field? Sometimes I have multiple emails with multiple subjects that are all related to a single project, and I'd like to somehow group them all together. I didn't want to use categories as I would need several hundred. Any thoughts or suggestions?

0
0
Reply
Diane Poremsky(@diane-poremsky)
Author
Reply to  Heather
March 24, 2016 11:39 pm
#197456

There isn't a native method build in but you can use redemption and a macro. I've got one laying around here somewhere.

2
0
Reply
Nikhil (@guest_196554)
February 17, 2016 12:19 pm
#196554

Hi Diane,

I am trying to set up an Outlook rule where Conversations started by me are assigned a particular category and I can focus on them first. Is there a way to achieve it? I couldn't locate in the default options in the rule menu.

Thanks in advance.
Nikhil

0
0
Reply
Diane Poremsky(@diane-poremsky)
Author
Reply to  Nikhil
February 17, 2016 6:04 pm
#196569

No, you can't do that using a rule. I'm not so sure you could do it using a script either.

0
0
Reply
Tracy (@guest_193242)
September 10, 2015 11:14 am
#193242

We're using Outlook 2013 and I have a user who has conversations turned on as well as the setting to View items in other folders. From what I can see, I have the same settings and I'm working fine - however - for this one user, she can no longer see her sent items in the conversation if she's then moved that sent email to another sub-folder under her inbox. In my view, even if I move my sent item to a sub-folder of "misc stuff", I still see it in my conversation in my inbox. It just changes from 'sent items' to 'misc stuff' in my view. What could we be missing here?

0
0
Reply
Roel Peeters (@guest_187536)
November 13, 2014 3:08 am
#187536

@Diane, I understand that but that isn`t the situation. The senders are completely different en didn't know each other.

0
0
Reply
Diane Poremsky (@guest_187537)
Reply to  Roel Peeters
November 13, 2014 8:03 am
#187537

Are they pop or imap accounts?

0
0
Reply
Roel Peeters (@guest_187434)
November 7, 2014 2:50 am
#187434

I see different subjects in the same discussion. The messages have no connection with each other. I work in Outlook 2010 without exchange. I don`t work with categories. How is that possible?

0
0
Reply
Diane Poremsky (@guest_187531)
Reply to  Roel Peeters
November 13, 2014 1:23 am
#187531

Were they senders involved in the original messages? If they create new messages by hitting reply and changing the subject and message body, outlook sees it as part of the thread because the conversation id is in the message header.

0
0
Reply
Sun W Kim (@guest_187650)
Reply to  Roel Peeters
November 17, 2014 10:49 am
#187650

I've seen what roel describes if the emails were migrated over from a different ISP or from a non outlook mailbox. The grouping may occur because they were migrated around the same time. We migrated over from groupwise and all the migrated email are clumped into one giant group. Emails that are created within outlook do t have this issue.

0
0
Reply
Sun Kim (@guest_186094)
September 19, 2014 1:29 pm
#186094

I'd like to see a way that we can group e-mails into one group. Sometimes we have different threads or subjects that appear as different conversations, but they are part of the same.

0
0
Reply
Diane Poremsky (@guest_186106)
Reply to  Sun Kim
September 19, 2014 6:46 pm
#186106

Yeah, that would be nice, to either combine conversations or split them.

2
0
Reply
Babs Peters (@guest_181633)
January 31, 2014 11:34 am
#181633

I tried 'group per conversation' for a few days and indeed.... ran into the problem you describe. Since I don't want Outlook to automatically assign a category, I stopped grouping per conversation. I now just sort on date field and nothing else.

But, Outlook still applies categories on new incoming mails (that Outlook thinks are part of a conversation). Can I somehow stop the program from doing that?

0
0
Reply
Diane Poremsky (@guest_181774)
Reply to  Babs Peters
February 8, 2014 12:56 am
#181774

When you set the category in the conversation view, you set it on the conversation header and that links it to the entire conversation. Switch to Group by conversation, remove the categories from the conversation by clicking on the group header. Apply Categories to individual messages under the group header if you want any to have a category.

0
0
Reply

Visit Slipstick Forums.
What's New at Slipstick.com

Latest EMO: Vol. 28 Issue 22

Support Services

Do you need help setting up Outlook, moving your email to a new computer, migrating or configuring Office 365, or just need some one-on-one assistance?

Subscribe to Exchange Messaging Outlook






Our Sponsors

CompanionLink
ReliefJet
  • Popular
  • Latest
  • WeekMonthAll
  • How to Remove the Primary Account from Outlook
  • Adjusting Outlook's Zoom Setting in Email
  • Outlook: Web Bugs & Blocked HTML Images
  • Save Sent Items in Shared Mailbox Sent Items folder
  • Move an Outlook Personal Folders .pst File
  • Create rules that apply to an entire domain
  • Use PowerShell to get a list of Distribution Group members
  • View Shared Calendar Category Colors
  • How to Create a Pick-a-Meeting Request
  • Remove a password from an Outlook *.pst File
  • Send Individual Messages when Sending Bulk Email
  • Centrally managed signatures in Office 365?
  • Create a rule to delete spam with no sender address
  • Open Outlook Folders using PowerShell or VBScript
  • Cannot add Recipients in To, CC, BCC fields on MacOS
  • Change Appointment Reminder Sounds
  • Messages appear duplicated in message list
  • Reset the New Outlook Profile
  • Delete Old Calendar Events using VBA
  • Use PowerShell or VBA to get Outlook folder creation date
Ajax spinner

Newest Code Samples

Delete Old Calendar Events using VBA

Use PowerShell or VBA to get Outlook folder creation date

Rename Outlook Attachments

Format Images in Outlook Email

Set Outlook Online or Offline using VBScript or PowerShell

List snoozed reminders and snooze-times

Search your Contacts using PowerShell

Filter mail when you are not the only recipient

Add Contact Information to a Task

Process Mail that was Auto Forwarded by a Rule

Recent Bugs List

Microsoft keeps a running list of issues affecting recently released updates at Fixes or workarounds for recent issues in Outlook for Windows.

Outlook for Mac Recent issues: Fixes or workarounds for recent issues in Outlook for Mac

Office Update History

Update history for supported Office versions is at Update history for Office

Outlook Suggestions and Feedback

Outlook Feedback covers Outlook as an email client, including Outlook Android, iOS, Mac, and Windows clients, as well as the browser extension (PWA) and Outlook on the web.

Use Outlook.com Feedback for suggestions or feedback about Outlook.com accounts.

Other Microsoft 365 applications and services




Windows 10 Issues

  • iCloud, Outlook 2016, and Windows 10
  • Outlook Links Won’t Open In Windows 10
  • Outlook can’t send mail in Windows 10: error Ox800CCC13
  • Missing Outlook data files after upgrading Windows?

Outlook Top Issues

  • The Windows Store Outlook App
  • The Signature or Stationery and Fonts button doesn’t work
  • Outlook’s New Account Setup Wizard
  • Outlook 2016: No BCM
  • Exchange Account Set-up Missing in Outlook 2016

Repair PST

Convert an OST to PST

Repair damaged PST file

Repair large PST File

Remove password from PST

Merge Two Data Files

Sync & Share Outlook Data

  • Share Calendar & Contacts
  • Synchronize two computers
  • Sync Calendar and Contacts Using Outlook.com
  • Sync Outlook & Android Devices
  • Sync Google Calendar with Outlook
  • Access Folders in Other Users Mailboxes

Contact Tools

Data Entry and Updating

Duplicate Checkers

Phone Number Updates

Contact Management Tools

Diane Poremsky [Outlook MVP]

Make a donation

Calendar Tools

Schedule Management

Calendar Printing Tools

Calendar Reminder Tools

Calendar Dates & Data

Time and Billing Tools

Meeting Productivity Tools

Duplicate Remover Tools

Mail Tools

Sending and Retrieval Tools

Mass Mail Tools

Compose Tools

Duplicate Remover Tools

Mail Tools for Outlook

Online Services

Productivity

Productivity Tools

Automatic Message Processing Tools

Special Function Automatic Processing Tools

Housekeeping and Message Management

Task Tools

Project and Business Management Tools

Choosing the Folder to Save a Sent Message In

Run Rules on messages after reading

Help & Suggestions

Submit Outlook Feature Requests

Slipstick Support Services

Home | Outlook User | Exchange Administrator | Office 365 | Outlook.com | Outlook Developer
Outlook for Mac | Common Problems | Utilities & Addins | Tutorials
Outlook & iCloud Issues | Outlook Apps
EMO Archives | About Slipstick | Advertise | Slipstick Forums
Submit New or Updated Outlook and Exchange Server Utilities

Send comments using our Feedback page
Copyright © 2023 Slipstick Systems. All rights reserved.
Slipstick Systems is not affiliated with Microsoft Corporation.

wpDiscuz

Sign up for Exchange Messaging Outlook

Our weekly Outlook & Exchange newsletter (bi-weekly during the summer)






Please note: If you subscribed to Exchange Messaging Outlook before August 2019, please re-subscribe.

Never see this message again.

You are going to send email to

Move Comment